Sardinia: The History No One Ever Told You 0 Commentaires

by Daniela Toti

Every journey holds a moment when the landscape stops being just a backdrop and becomes a query. For me, it happened in front of a nuraghe, on a clear morning with a gentle breeze rustling through the Mediterranean vegetation that surrounded it. The dark, imposing stones seemed to breathe. They didn’t speak words, but beneath the surface pulsed a story I had never been told.

At school, Sardinia was barely mentioned: a blank map, a few notes on mines or beaches, and then silence again. Yet, standing before that millennia-old stone tower, the question became inevitable: how is it possible that one of the most extraordinary civilizations of the Mediterranean remained hidden in the shadows?

I found a first fragment of the answer in a book by Fiorenzo Caterini, La Mano Destra della Storia (The Right Hand of History). It's not just an essay, it’s a lens that flips perspectives and forces you to look at Sardinia, and at history in general, in a completely different way.

Caterini uses the image of the right hand to represent official historiography, the one that appears in textbooks and defines what is important and what is not—what becomes “history.” The left hand instead is unofficial history: preserved by independent scholars, passionate storytellers, oral memory, and forgotten archives.

For Sardinia, history has been written for centuries only by the right hand. The result has been a partial narrative, with entire chapters erased. The left hand, however, has continued to protect fragments of truth, whispering names and dates, just not in classrooms or textbooks.

This was no accident, nor oversight. According to Caterini, at least three main reasons emerge:

1- Savoyard prejudice: figures like General Alberto Ferrero della Marmora, author of the most important map of Sardinia in the 19th century, detailed mountains and coasts but paid little attention to ancient history, leaving the Nuragic civilization in the shadows. Similarly, General Luigi Cadorna described Sardinian soldiers as undisciplined and unreliable, unfounded judgments that fuelled the stereotype of Sardinia as backward and problematic.

2- Post-Unification narrative: After Italy’s unification, a national story was written that began in Rome and Florence, passing through Turin and Milan. It was a tale of unity and central Italian identity. Sardinia didn’t fit: its cultural autonomy, pre-Roman and medieval history, and its role as a Mediterranean crossroads clashed with the myth of unity being promoted.

3- Academic silence: The most silent, yet perhaps most powerful blow. For over a century, the Nuragic civilization was completely absent from Italian school curricula. Entire generations grew up unaware that their land, or the land they might visit, was once home to an ancient and remarkable civilization.

Today, giving voice to this story is not only a cultural duty, but also an act of identity. It’s a way to reclaim pride and roots. It’s an invitation to go beyond the cliché of sun, sea, and salt, and let yourself be surprised by an island that also holds Nuraghi, Giant Tombs, Water Sanctuaries, Coastal Towers, and Stone Statues that tell ancient myths.

As I often write in my articles for the Gabbiano Azzurro Hotel & Suites  - see Sardìgna meravizosa, Sardinia, So Unknown, Sardinia: not only sun, salt and sea - traveling in Sardinia can be a journey through time: every archaeological site is a page that the official history books never printed, but one that can still be read as you walk among the stones. Visiting The Nuraghi, listening to legends told by local custodians, hiking paths that lead to lesser-known sites, this is where history, when encountered in person, stops being dust in archives and becomes light, wind, and stone beneath your fingers.

===